The overlap between Magic: The Gathering and online poker is one of the strangest and most interesting elements between card games. The fantasy card game Wizards of the Coast built has supplied poker with some of its sharpest players over the past couple of decades.
Some have left Magic behind for good, while others split their weeks between Pro Tour drafts and multi-tabling sessions on legit platforms like uspoker.com.
Names on Both Leaderboards
Some notable names appear on the crossover player list. One of the most notable is Jon Finkel, known as “Jonny Magic” and widely regarded as one of the best Magic players of all time. He also spent many years playing high-level poker tournaments alongside fellow Magic stars David Williams and Noah Boeken.
Williams was a Magic pro as a teenager and finished in second place at the 2004 World Series of Poker Main Event, going on to earn over $9.5 million in live tournaments according to Hendon Mob database figures. He attributes much of his success to the analytical demands of Magic and the long hours spent at the tables.
Eric Froehlich has a similar story. He began playing online poker when he was 18 and became the youngest ever player at the time in 2005 to win a WSOP bracelet. He added a second bracelet in 2006. Froehlich was also inducted into the Magic Hall of Fame in 2015, and has called the card game “a great training ground for poker.”
Other Magic players worth mentioning are Frenchman Gabriel Nassif, who was the Magic Player of the Year in 2004 and a two-time Pro Tour champion, who turned into a regular WSOP grinder. Other notable names who came up through the Magic ranks before building serious poker careers include Justin Bonomo, Isaac Haxton, Adam Levy, and Brock Parker.
What Skills Translate?
The two games on the surface don’t look too similar. One has dragons and counterspells through self-built decks and the other is confined to strict parameters about the cards. However, the core skills are very similar.
Probability plays a big part in both card games. A competitive Magic player is constantly calculating the odds of drawing a specific card on a specific turn, often with many “outs” spread across the deck. This is similar to how a poker player determines the likelihood of certain cards appearing in a given round based on what they already know.
Decision-making with hidden information is another key skill. Magic players try to narrow down what an opponent might have left in their hand based on what has been played already and what was held back. Poker players call this skill hand reading and assigning ranges.
Perhaps the most important crossover is variance. Every strong Magic player has lost a match to a hand with no playable cards, no matter how well they’ve built their deck or played. Learning to separate a good decision from a good result, continuing to follow the process during a bad run, is the mental discipline that is vital across both card games.
Any Key Differences?
There are some limits to the crossover. Magic is a game where there’s constant novelty, as new sets release several times a year and rewrite the possibilities of the game. This contrasts with poker, which is a fixed game and the same scenarios often arise again and again.
Poker also doesn’t have the creative element of deckbuilding or creating a unique strategy the night before a tournament. Despite these differences, the pipeline of talent going from Magic to poker doesn’t look like slowing down any time soon.
Stick with us here at mtgrocks.com: the best site for Magic: The Gathering coverage. Be sure to check out our deckbuilder for your next big brew, and our brand new MTG Rocks Podcast!